Cozy up with a bowl of comfort from these top local soup havens
When the chill in the air calls for something warm and satisfying, nothing beats a steaming bowl of soup. Whether you’re craving a creamy bisque, a hearty chowder, or a time-honored family recipe, Long Island boasts an incredible selection of soup spots that cater to every taste. From Greek classics to Italian comfort food and everything in between, these local eateries will keep you coming back for more. Check out our recommendations for the Best Spots for Soup on Long Island this winter!
Copenhagen Bakery – Northport
Address: 75 Woodbine Avenue, Northport
Copenhagen Bakery is more than just pastries; their soup menu is a star attraction. Offering over 15 varieties, including Hungarian Mushroom, Beef Stew, and Potato Leek, they have something for everyone. Soups are available in 12 oz ($7.50), 16 oz ($8.95), or 32 oz ($14.95) sizes—perfect for any appetite and rotate often. Make sure to check their website to see their daily soup offerings.
The Chowder Bar – Bay Shore
Address: 123 Maple Avenue, Bay Shore
If chowder is your thing, look no further. The Chowder Bar serves Manhattan, New England, and Long Island clam chowders alongside French Onion Au Gratin and a seafood chowder brimming with flavor ($18.50). With cup and bowl options starting at $7, it’s a must-visit for soup lovers.
NY Soup Exchange – Garden City
Address: 945 Franklin Avenue, Garden City
The NY Soup Exchange lives up to its name with a rotating menu of fresh, daily soups made from scratch. Each bowl is a taste of comfort and nostalgia, making it a favorite among locals. Make sure to check their website for daily offerings.
Mama Soup– Mineola
Address: The Benchmark, 170 Old Country Road, Mineola
With recipes passed down for generations, Mama Soup delivers homemade goodness. Choose from options like Beef Barley, Chicken Pot Pie Soup, or a creamy Seafood Bisque. Prices range from $7.49 to $19.98, with hearty servings perfect for sharing—or not.
Sweet Tomato – Oyster Bay
Address: 91 Audrey Ave, Oyster Bay, NY
Sweet Tomato in Oyster Bay offers homestyle comfort food and variety of hearty soups to choose from. From classics like Tomato Bisque to Chicken Noodle to vegan and gluten-free options like Veggie Quinoa or Caribbean Red Lentil, there’s a soup for everyone. Make sure to ask about their soup of the day when visiting.
NY Bone Broths – Franklin Square
Address: 402 Franklin Avenue, Franklin Square
Known for its health-focused approach, NY Bone Broths offers nutrient-packed soups like Thai Butternut Squash and Moroccan Lentil. Starting at $8.95, these broths not only warm the soul but also nourish the body.
Parea, That Little Greek Place – Huntington
Address: 360 New York Avenue, Huntington
Parea delivers authentic Greek flavors with its Avgolemono soup, alongside rotating Soup of the Day. Priced at $5.50 for a cup or $10.75 for a quart, it’s a perfect stop for a quick, comforting meal.
Nicky’s Clam Bar – Bay Shore
Address: 99 Maple Ave Suite A, Bay Shore
Nicky’s Clam Bar, although closed for the season until March, recently won Best Soups in Suffolk County in the Local’s Choice Awards. Nicky’s serves up a Manhattan Clam Chowder, a Vegetarian Minestrone, their famous Seafood Bisque, and even more! Make sure to check Nicky’s Clam Bar out when they reopen in March.
Stay Warm at Local Spots for Soup on Long Island
Whether you’re a fan of hearty stews, creamy bisques, or light broths, these Long Island soup spots have something to warm your heart and satisfy your cravings. Supporting these local gems not only guarantees a delicious meal but also helps sustain the vibrant culinary scene that makes Long Island special. So grab a spoon, visit one of these soup havens, and enjoy a comforting taste of home—right in your neighborhood.
For the Best French Onion Soup Spots on Long Island, click HERE!
